Credit Eric Schultz, by way of Related Press
Donald J. Trump stated Saturday that he would order surveillance of â??certain mosquesâ? to combat terrorism after the Paris attacks and claimed to have watched as â??thousands and thousands of folks have been cheeringâ? while the Globe Trade Center towers fell on Sept. 11, 2001.
In a rally at the Birmingham-Jefferson Convention Complicated in Birmingham, Ala., Mr. Trump, who is in search of the Republican presidential nomination, dismissed accounts of his apparent assistance for creating a registry of Muslims in the United States as an effort by the news media to entrap him. He then seemed to clarify that concept on Saturday, saying he wanted a database of refugees getting into the nation from Syria and adding, to cheers, â??I want surveillance of particular mosques, O.K.?â?
â??Weâ??ve had it ahead of and weâ??ll have it again,â? he added. Mr. Trump has lately spoken of the New York Police Departmentâ??s use of informants in mosques soon after the Sept. 11 attacks.
Donald Trump Sets Off a Furor With Contact to Register Muslims in the U.S.NOV. 20, 2015
It is unclear regardless of whether a database of Syrian refugees would be markedly different from the records currently being kept in screening by federal agencies. But Mr. Trump, the leading Republican candidate in some polls, has been probably the most strident of all the contenders on the issue of regardless of whether to accept refugees following the Paris attacks, raising the possibility that some extremists could slip in amongst them and telling the crowd Saturday that should he win the presidency, the refugees are â??going back, we canâ??t have them.â?
Credit Eric Schultz, via Related Press
Earlier this year, Mr. Trump said that accepting a restricted quantity of refugees from Syria was a humanitarian decision.
Possibly the most striking comment of the day was his recounting of the Sept. 11 attacks as he talked about the safety landscape considering that the Paris massacre:
â??Hey, I watched when the Planet Trade Center came tumbling down. And I watched in Jersey City, New Jersey, where thousands and thousands of men and women were cheering as that developing was coming down. Thousands of people were cheering. So somethingâ??s going on. Weâ??ve got to find out what it is.â?
It was not clear what Mr. Trump was referring to. There had been cheers of assistance in some Middle Eastern countries that day, which were broadcast on television. But a persistent Net rumor of Muslims celebrating in Paterson, N.J., was discounted by police officials at the time. A search of news accounts from that period shows no reports of mass cheering in Jersey City.
Continue reading the principal story
History suggests that every single partyâ??s eventual nominee will emerge from 2015 in 1 of the leading two or three positions, as measured by endorsements, fund-raising and polling.
OPEN Interactive Graphic
Ibrahim Hooper, a spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations, said the response of Muslim-Americans on Sept. 11 was disgust.
â??I know simply because I wrote it,â? he mentioned of the councilâ??s reaction, adding that if Mr. Trump had evidence of cheering, he ought to present it.
Hope Hicks, a spokeswoman for Mr. Trump, would not elaborate on his comments his aides have repeatedly declined to make him offered to address the controversies over some of his statements. Ms. Hicks stated only that Mr. Trump had drawn an â??unprecedentedâ? crowd of 10,000 in Birmingham, adding, â??Mr. Trumpâ??s speech was excellent and unbelievably effectively received.â?
Given that the Nov. 13 attacks in Paris by Islamic extremists, which killed 130 individuals, the national mood has turned against admitting refugees from Syria, exactly where the Islamic State has taken control of certain areas, a poll by Bloomberg Politics showed final week. And Mr. Trump has been riding a wave of anger and mistrust of government and politicians because he entered the race in June.
Continue reading the primary story
Mr. Trumpâ??s calls for surveillance came following he mentioned earlier in the week that he supported closing some mosques. He has not been alone in creating such calls a top donor to Hillary Rodham Clinton also urged such surveillance in the wake of the Paris attacks. The donor, Haim Saban, later stated he had misspoken.
The rest of Saturdayâ??s speech was a classic Trump efficiency, a crowd-pleasing stream of boasts, humor and mockery. Referring to George E. Pataki, the former New York governor who has been lagging badly in polls and was 1 of a number of opponents to seek airtime from NBC right after Mr. Trump hosted the networkâ??s â??Saturday Evening Reside,â? he said: â??They could give him 12 â??Saturday Evening Lives,â?? an hour and a half a evening â?? not going to have any effect.â?
At 1 point for the duration of the rally, a protester whom Mr. Trump known as to have ejected â?? â??Get him the hell out of right here,â? he ordered security guards â?? was punched and kicked by some attendees, CNN reported.
The protester, who wore a shirt saying â??Black Lives Matterâ? and refused to leave the rally, was hit by roughly a half-dozen attendees, CNN said. The police told the network that the man had not essential health-related attention.
Ms. Hicks did not respond to an e mail asking about the removal of the protester.
Below assault from Democrats and Republicans alike, Donald J. Trump on Friday drew back from his call for a mandatory registry of Muslims in the United States, attempting to quell one of the ugliest controversies yet in a presidential campaign like couple of other people.
The daylong furor capped a week of 1-upmanship amongst Republican presidential candidates as to who could sound toughest about stopping terrorism right after the Nov. 13 attacks in Paris. Polls show the national mood has soured on accepting refugees from Syria amid concerns about prospective terrorist attacks within the United States.
Mr. Trump’s talk of a national database of Muslims, very first in an interview published on Thursday by Yahoo News and later in an exchange with an NBC News reporter, seemed the culmination of months of heated debate about illegal immigration as an urgent danger to Americans’ personal security.
It came as Mr. Trump has regained some momentum in the Republican presidential race, with polls showing his support on the rise nationally considering that the Paris attacks, and Ben Carson’s on the decline.
By Friday, though, he appeared to pull back slightly from the idea. In a post on Twitter, Mr. Trump complained that it was a reporter, not he, who had 1st raised the idea of a database. And his campaign manager, Corey Lewandowski, insisted that Mr. Trump had been asked leading inquiries by the NBC reporter under “blaring music” and that he had in thoughts a terrorist watch list, not a registry of Muslims.
Still, nowhere, even on Friday, did Mr. Trump, who has seldom acknowledged becoming at fault in a campaign predicated on his strength as a leader, clearly state that he was opposed to the idea of a registry of Muslims.
For months, Mr. Trump has set the tone and pace of the Republican main, forcing his rivals to respond to his statements and in some situations to attempt to emulate his style and positions. His periodic eruptions have seemed to energy his campaign he has denigrated Senator John McCain’s record in Vietnam simply because he was a prisoner of war, stated that the Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly was bleeding from “wherever,” insulted Carly Fiorina’s looks and read Senator Lindsey Graham’s cellphone quantity aloud ahead of a crowd of thousands. By means of it all, his supporters have held firm.
Yet rivals who have been pulled sharply to the proper by Mr. Trump on troubles like immigration broke with him this time — a uncommon public distancing by politicians who have seemed handcuffed out of worry that swinging back at Mr. Trump would make them the butt of his next joke or offend his supporters.
In the Yahoo interview on Thursday, which came on the heels of his calls to close some mosques and very carefully monitor others, Mr. Trump recommended, with couple of specifics, that he would impose new measures to deal with terrorism.
“We’re going to have to do things that we never ever did just before. And some folks are going to be upset about it, but I feel that now everybody is feeling that safety is going to rule,” he stated. “And particular issues will be done that we never ever believed would come about in this nation in terms of details and learning about the enemy. And so we’re going to have to do particular issues that had been frankly unthinkable a year ago.”
Asked by the Yahoo reporter about the possibility of a database for Muslims or “a form of special identification that noted their religion,” Mr. Trump did not reject either concept. Later that day, as Mr. Trump left a campaign event in Iowa, an NBC reporter followed up. Asked if he would set up a database to track Muslims, Mr. Trump replied, “I would undoubtedly implement that. Definitely.”
Asked about the effect that would have, however, he replied, “It would quit folks from coming in illegally” — probably suggesting that Mr. Trump, who has vowed to develop a “beautiful” wall along the Mexican border, was not focused on the query.
And when the NBC reporter approached Mr. Trump a second time and asked about the distinction in between registering Muslims and what occurred to Jews in Nazi Germany, Mr. Trump grew impatient: “You tell me,” he stated.
Mr. Trump’s remarks took hours to circulate extensively over social media. But his seemingly serious consideration for the concept of treating an entire religious group with suspicion created the threat of a new set of problems for a Republican Celebration currently struggling to appeal beyond its largely white political base. The celebration has also spent years objecting to what Republicans get in touch with government overreach by President Obama.
By Friday morning, numerous Democrats, some Republicans and a cross-section of religious leaders were denouncing Mr. Trump’s remarks.
Jeb Bush, the former governor of Florida, responded on CNBC by saying, “You talk about closing mosques, you talk about registering men and women — that is just incorrect.”
Senator Ted Cruz of Texas, who is campaigning on a platform in which “religious freedom” plays a main element but is also in search of to inherit Mr. Trump’s supporters need to his campaign falter, hit on a gentler way of dissociating himself from the idea. “I’m a large fan of Donald Trump’s, but I’m not a fan of government registries,” he stated in Sioux City, Iowa.
But Mr. Cruz also accused the news media of attempting to divide the Republican Party, in effect siding with Mr. Trump against a typical enemy.
“I recognize that the media would love to get me and other candidates to attack Donald Trump,” Mr. Cruz said. “There could be other candidates who want to do that. I ain’t gonna do it.”
Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey, who has gained some traction by virtually camping out in New Hampshire, belittled Mr. Trump without naming him. “The indiscriminate closing of mosques or the establishment of a national registry primarily based on religion will do practically nothing to keep us safer and shows a lack of understanding on how to effectively prevent terrorist attacks,” he said in a statement.
Mr. Trump’s remarks drew condemnation not only from American Muslims but also from Christian, Jewish and interfaith leaders.
“We had anticipated a rise in Islamophobic rhetoric throughout the election cycle, but we by no means thought it would hark back to the rhetoric of the 1930s,” mentioned Ibrahim Hooper, the communications director for the Council on American-Islamic Relations.
Russell D. Moore, the president of the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, mentioned, “I do believe it is scary when we have candidates speaking about shutting down homes of worship, about possessing badges for religious groups. That ought to alarm every American.”
Ari Fleischer, the former press secretary beneath President George W. Bush and a board member of the Republican Jewish Coalition, criticized Mr. Trump’s remarks as intolerable. But he also stated that, even though some have believed that Mr. Trump’s supporters would gravitate toward much more significant-minded candidates soon after the Paris attacks, he anticipated the opposite.
“People rally to strength,” Mr. Fleischer stated.
This entry passed by means of the Complete-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on a person else’s web site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.